Question 1
Statements:
All durable are useful.
No useful is a reliable.
Conclusions:
I. No durable is a reliable.
II. All reliable being durable is a possibility.
Definite Conclusion Analysis:
Venn Diagram:
Step 1: All durable are useful → durable inside useful
Step 2: No useful is a reliable → useful and reliable completely separate
Step 3: Since durable inside useful, durable also doesn't touch reliable
Analytical Method:
All durable are useful (A) + No useful is a reliable (E) = A + E = E
Result: No durable is a reliable
Checking Conclusions:
✓ Conclusion I: "No durable is a reliable" - DEFINITE CONCLUSION - FOLLOWS
✗ Conclusion II: "All reliable being durable is a possibility"
Since definite negative exists ("No durable is a reliable"), this possibility is IMPOSSIBLE
DOES NOT FOLLOW
Important Rule: When definite negative conclusion exists between terms, positive possibility becomes FALSE.
Answer: Only conclusion I follows
Venn Diagram:
Step 1: All durable are useful → durable inside useful
Step 2: No useful is a reliable → useful and reliable completely separate
Step 3: Since durable inside useful, durable also doesn't touch reliable
Analytical Method:
All durable are useful (A) + No useful is a reliable (E) = A + E = E
Result: No durable is a reliable
Checking Conclusions:
✓ Conclusion I: "No durable is a reliable" - DEFINITE CONCLUSION - FOLLOWS
✗ Conclusion II: "All reliable being durable is a possibility"
Since definite negative exists ("No durable is a reliable"), this possibility is IMPOSSIBLE
DOES NOT FOLLOW
Important Rule: When definite negative conclusion exists between terms, positive possibility becomes FALSE.
Answer: Only conclusion I follows