Question 1
Convert the following to standard logical form:
"A number is prime only if it is greater than 1"
What is the correct conditional representation?
Step 1: Understand 'only if' statements
'P only if Q' means 'If P, then Q' (P → Q)
This is DIFFERENT from 'If Q then P' (Q → P)
Key insight: 'only if' introduces a NECESSARY condition
Q is necessary for P (P cannot be true without Q)
Step 2: Identify components
Statement: A number is prime only if it is greater than 1
P: Number is prime, G: Greater than 1
Step 3: Convert to logical form
Logical form: P → G
Equivalent: If a number is prime, then it is greater than 1
Step 4: Important distinction
Note: Being greater than 1 is necessary but not sufficient
'Only if' ≠ 'If and only if'
'Only if' gives one direction only (→)
'If and only if' gives both directions (↔)
'P only if Q' means 'If P, then Q' (P → Q)
This is DIFFERENT from 'If Q then P' (Q → P)
Key insight: 'only if' introduces a NECESSARY condition
Q is necessary for P (P cannot be true without Q)
Step 2: Identify components
Statement: A number is prime only if it is greater than 1
P: Number is prime, G: Greater than 1
Step 3: Convert to logical form
Logical form: P → G
Equivalent: If a number is prime, then it is greater than 1
Step 4: Important distinction
Note: Being greater than 1 is necessary but not sufficient
'Only if' ≠ 'If and only if'
'Only if' gives one direction only (→)
'If and only if' gives both directions (↔)