ReasoningAbility.com

Box Size Comparison: Worksheet 2 - Beginner Practice Box Size Comparison BEGINNER

Ready to master Box Size Comparison? This entry level practice worksheet (2/10) presents 20 beginner-level challenges. Focus area: pattern recognition. Learn to solve box size comparison reasoning questions, handle box size comparison practice, and perfect box size comparison for competitive exams with our step-by-step solutions.

📝 Worksheet 2 of 10 • 20 questions • ⏱️ Estimated time: 20 minutes • 🎯 Beginner level

What you'll learn in this worksheet:
Your progress through Box Size Comparison
Worksheet 2 of 10 (11% complete)

Question 1

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 2

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 3

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 4

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 5

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 6

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 7

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 8

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 9

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 10

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 11

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 12

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 13

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 14

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 15

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 16

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 17

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 18

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 19

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)

Question 20

Five boxes P, Q, R, S, and T of different sizes are stacked vertically (positions 1 to 5 from bottom to top). The stacking rule is: larger boxes must be placed below smaller boxes. Size relationships: - Box P is larger than box Q but smaller than box R - Box S is the smallest - Box T is larger than box R - Box Q is larger than box S If box S is removed from the stack, which box will be at position 4 (counting from the bottom)?
Step-by-step Solution:

1. Establish size relationships:
- P > Q and R > P → So R > P > Q
- S is smallest → S is less than all others
- T > R
- Q > S

2. Combine all inequalities:
- From T > R and R > P > Q, we get: T > R > P > Q
- From Q > S, we get: T > R > P > Q > S

3. Complete size order (largest to smallest):
T > R > P > Q > S

4. Apply stacking rule (larger below smaller):
- Position 1 (bottom): T (largest)
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q
- Position 5 (top): S (smallest)

5. Remove box S from position 5:

6. Remaining stack (4 boxes):
- Position 1: T
- Position 2: R
- Position 3: P
- Position 4: Q

7. Answer: Box Q is at position 4

Verification:
- T > R ✓ (pos1 vs pos2)
- R > P ✓ (pos2 vs pos3)
- P > Q ✓ (pos3 vs pos4)
- Q > S ✓ (pos4 vs pos5 before removal)
Previous Worksheet Next Worksheet